Search results : 995

Refine your search
Results display : Short Long
IRIS 2015-7:1/23 [NL] Court of Appeal overturns judgment against broadcaster for criticising telecom provider

In its judgment of 24 April 2015, the Dutch Court of Appeal of Amsterdam refused to declare an item about a telecom provider a tortious act, even though it was in bad taste. A Dutch broadcasting organisation called BNN-VARA, the appellant in this case, broadcast a show in which it devoted attention to various complaints about the telecom provider Pretium, the respondent. The show started with an item that told the story of an old lady who had been unable to use her telephone line in the final weeks of her life, because of a failure of her telephone company. Sober music and shots of one of the old...

IRIS 2015-7:1/22 [NL] Court applies Google Spain again: no right to be forgotten for convicted criminals

On 1 May 2015, the North Netherlands District Court ruled in a case regarding the request to have certain search results pertaining to the plaintiff’s criminal history delisted from Google Search based on search queries limited to his name. This is another judgment in a series of Dutch cases concerning the application of the CJEU’s Google Spain judgment (see for a recent example IRIS 2015-5/25). The plaintiff was convicted for killing his wife, the mother of his children, in 2007. He was sentenced to 12 years in prison and treatment under a hospital order (terbeschikkingstelling - TBS). Among the...

IRIS 2015-7:1/20 [IE] High Court grants injunction preventing broadcast of businessman’s banking details

On 21 May 2015, a High Court judge granted an injunction preventing the public broadcaster RTÉ from broadcasting confidential banking information concerning an Irish businessman. The judge announced that he would publish a “redacted” judgment at a later date and ruled that some of his conclusions could not be reported by the media until lawyers agreed on which parts of the judgment should be redacted. The 48-page redacted judgment was published on 3 June 2015. But, on 29 May 2015 and before the redacted judgment was published, a Member of Parliament disclosed some of the confidential banking information...

IRIS 2015-7:1/19 [GB] New guidelines on restrictions on reporting proceedings in criminal courts

A new set of guidelines on open justice and reporting restrictions in the criminal courts has been published by the Lord Chief Justice, the News Media Association (NMA), the Society of Editors and the Media Lawyers Association, who were all involved in their preparation. The new guidelines take account of recent changes relating to anonymity for those under 18 and in cases concerned with female genital mutilation. The basic principle is that of open justice, requiring that proceedings must be held in public, evidence must be communicated publicly and fair, accurate and contemporaneous media reporting...

IRIS 2015-7:1/18 [GB] Gulati v. MGN Ltd: High Court awards damages in phone-hacking cases

The cases concerned claims based on infringements of privacy rights as a result of the unauthorised access by one person of another’s voicemail/answering machine (phone hacking). The defendant was the proprietor of three newspapers - the Daily Mirror, the Sunday Mirror and The People. The claimants were eight persons in the public eye, such as actors, sportsmen or people with an association with such people. The claimants argued that journalists listened to messages left on the claimants’ respective voicemail services and also listened to the voicemail messages left by the claimants on the phones...