Search results : 995

Refine your search
Results display : Short Long
IRIS 2016-5:1/1 European Court of Human Rights: Bédat v. Switzerland (Grand Chamber)

In a judgment of 29 March 2016, the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in Bédat v. Switzerland found that a criminal conviction of a journalist, Arnaud Bédat, for having published documents covered by investigative secrecy in a criminal case is no violation of Article 10 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR). The Grand Chamber is of the opinion that the Swiss authorities acted within their margin of appreciation and that recourse to criminal proceedings and the penalty imposed on the journalist did not amount to a disproportionate interference in the exercise...

IRIS 2016-4:1/27 [US] Life story of an Iraq war veteran may be filmed without his consent

On 17 February 2016, the 9th Circuit US Court of Appeals ruled that the First Amendment to the US Constitution, which, inter alia, governs freedom of speech, protects the filming of the life story of even an unknown person. The appellant was an Iraq war veteran. The case concerned the film “The Hurt Locker”, which is a war movie that shows the work of a bomb disposal squad in the Iraq war. The appellant claimed that the film’s main protagonist was based on him and sued its director and screenwriter, stating that the film was defamatory and breached his personality rights (“right of publicity”),...

IRIS 2016-4:1/22 [NL] Court rules on investigative TV programme’s methods and the right to privacy

The Dutch TV show Onopgeloste zaken investigates unsolved cases, which usually leads to a confrontation with a person on camera. In this particular case, a person confronted about possible wrongdoing considered the confrontation to be a violation of his privacy and brought proceedings against the TV show. The claimant was approached by a family, asking him to store their furniture while they were renovating their house. Upon completion of the renovation they wanted their furniture back, but it seemed that the claimant’s company could not be reached by phone or mail. Thereupon the family approached...

IRIS 2016-4:1/15 [GB] Court of Appeal rules on “stop power” under Terrorism Act and journalistic material

The case concerned the legality of the stopping and searching of David Miranda at Heathrow Airport in 2013, who was believed to be carrying information relating to the Snowden disclosures which had been published in The Guardian newspaper (see IRIS 2016-2/28). Miranda is the spouse of Glenn Greenwald, a journalist who at the material time was working for The Guardian. The police relied on the Terrorism Act 2000 (TACT), and the High Court held that the actions of the police were legal, but gave leave to appeal. The Court of Appeal suggested that there were three questions before it: (a) the definition...

IRIS 2016-4:1/14 [GB] Court of Appeal rules on principle of “open justice” and national security

Erol Incedal, a 28-year-old law student from south London, was arrested in October 2013 and found to be in possession of a bomb-making manual on a memory card hidden inside his mobile phone case. He had been stopped for speeding in an E-class Mercedes, and a piece of paper inside his glasses case had a note of the address of a property owned by ex-prime minister Tony Blair and his wife. Following an almost totally secret trial, he was cleared of plotting a terrorist attack on the streets of London but was imprisoned for having the manual in his possession. Only 10 of the almost 70 hours of evidence...