Search results : 995

Refine your search
Results display : Short Long
IRIS 2012-4:1/26 [GB] Supreme Court Decides that Freedom of Information Act has Only Limited Application to the BBC

The UK Supreme Court has now determined the final appeal in the “Sugar” case relating to the application of the Freedom of Information Act to the BBC (see IRIS 2010-3/25 and IRIS 2009-4/15). The BBC is listed as an organisation covered by the Freedom of Information Act that provides public rights of access to official information, but on in relation to information held “for purposes other than those of journalism, art or literature.” In 2005 Mr Sugar had applied under the Act for disclosure of the Balen Report, an internal management report relating to the question of whether BBC coverage of the...

IRIS 2012-4:1/22 [ES] Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Arguments against Sinde Law

The new anti-piracy law in Spain (the so called Sinde Law after former Ministry Ángeles González Sinde, see IRIS 2012-2/18, IRIS 2011-3/17 and IRIS 2011-2/23) has hit a setback after the country’s Supreme Court agreed to hear an appeal by the Asociación de Internautas (Association of Web Users), who claimed the Sinde Law is unconstitutional. Spanish copyright laws have been criticised for over a decade after various courts ruled that the file-sharing of unlicensed content was not illegal, hindering civil legal action even against those who provide software or web services that enable copyright...

IRIS 2012-4:1/21 [ES] Constitutional Court on Use of Hidden Cameras in the Journalistic Field

On 30 January 2012, the Spanish Constitutional Court declared the use of hidden cameras in a journalistic field to be unconstitutional, regardless of the public relevance of the investigation’s purpose. This statement arises from a lawsuit filed against a Spanish TV production company for the infringement of the rights to honour and to personal portrayal, when a journalist went to an appointment with an estheticienne (beautician) posing as a patient. The appointment was at the beautician’s home, which was partly used as her office, where the journalist recorded the voice and image of the beautician...

IRIS 2012-4:1/17 [DE] No Unlimited Media Reporting on Public Court Hearing

The criminal procedure against a famous TV weather presenter accused of rape, which has attracted huge media interest, has also repeatedly occupied Cologne’s civil courts in recent months. The journalist, who has since been acquitted, launched numerous lawsuits - some of which were successful - following media reporting of the case which he believed had infringed his personality rights (see IRIS 2012-3/16 and IRIS 2012-1/19). In three judgments issued on 14 February 2012, the Oberlandesgericht Köln (Cologne Appeal Court - OLG) considered the extent to which questioning of the accused about his...

IRIS 2012-4:1/16 [DE] OVG Rules WDR Must Provide Information under NRW Freedom of Information Act

In a ruling of 9 February 2012, the Oberverwaltungsgericht Münster (Münster Administrative Appeal Court - OVG) overturned the decision of the lower-instance court (see IRIS 2010-2/11) and ruled that Westdeutscher Rundfunk (WDR) is, in principle, obliged to provide information to a journalist under the North Rhine-Westphalia Informationsfreiheitsgesetz (Freedom of Information Act - IFG NRW). The procedure followed a journalist’s request to WDR for information about which companies it cooperated with and how much money was involved. The journalist had requested this information because he suspected...